Minimising Line Losses in RE Systems
Minimising Line Losses In RE Systems
Select wire of the correct diameter for your renewable energy system
storage | electric circuitIn most
renewable energy systems low voltage DC (direct current) electricity is generated. When this is from a
wind turbine generator or a
hydro electricity generator there is usually quite a distance between the location of the generator and the
battery bank or
power inverter.
If the wire (cable) taking this electricity is not thick enough you may potentially lose vast amounts of expensively generated power in
resistive line losses - basically speaking, you will be heating the wire rather than charging your batteries. However, with the recent jump in the price of copper, if you choose wire which is unnecessarily thick, the extra costs incurred will seriously get in the way of your generating
free (not that such a thing exists) electricity.
In an ideal situation
line losses should be kept at or below 10% - i.e. no more than 10% of the power you generate should be lost in the wires you use to transmit it to your
battery bank or
inverter.
What You Need to Know to Calculate Line Losses
Calculating your likely line losses is quite a simple process requiring no more than a standard calculator and a little knowledge - supplied here.
NOTE - If you are not interested in the mathematics then scroll down to the final equations so you can start making some calculations for your system.
NEW You can also click here to go to our new
Line Losses Calculator which will automatically calculate the
size of wire you require for your system, or calculate the
line losses for a given wire size.
The one
constant you need is the
resistivity of copper (
rho) = 0.000000017 Ohms per metre at 20 degrees Celcius.
You should know the
charging voltage (peak) and
current (peak) of your generator. The charging voltage is always higher than the rated voltage of a generator - e.g. a 12 Volt solar panel will actually have an open circuit voltage of at least 18 Volts. You need to use the higher value in your calculations.
The
cross-sectional area of your wire is given by multiplying the radius (half the diameter) of the wire squared by PI (3.14159).
If the wire is made up of multple strands then the cross-sectional area is given by squaring the radius of one strand and multiplying it by PI and then by the number of strands.
Once you know these values you are ready to calculate the resistance of your power lines and therefore your power losses.
Calculating Line Losses
The resistance of a length of wire is equal to 1,000,000 multiplied by the length of the wire (in metres) multiplied by
rho and then divided by the cross sectional area of the wire (in square mm). Note that 1,000,000 square mm is equal to one square metre - hence the factor of 1,000,000 in the equation.
For example:
A wire 200 metres long with a cross sectional area of 2.25 square mm has a
resistance of:
(1,000,000 * length * 0.000000017) / 2.25 = 1.51 ohms
The
power loss is given by the square of the current in amps multiplied by the resistance of the wire, so with a 30 amp peak power output wind turbine generator and the example wire above, the
power loss is:
30 * 30 * 1.51 = 1,359 Watts
If the example wind turbine has a charging voltage of 65 volts (typical of a 48 Volt rated wind turbine) then the peak power output of this wind turbine would be equal to the charging voltage multiplied by the current = 65 x 30 = 1,950 Watts.
Therefore of the 1.95kW generated by the
wind turbine, 1.36kW would be lost as line losses = 70%!
100 * 1.36/1.95 = 70%
Using the Equation to Select wire for Your System
All the mathematics above can be simplified into one easy (relatively) equation:
| Power Loss (%) = |
| 1.7 * Current * Wire Length |
| Charging Voltage * Wire Area |
|
In order to choose wire for your own renewable energy system you just need to choose the amount of line losses you are willing to accept (e.g. 10%), feed the numbers into the equation below, and out comes the minimum cross-sectional area of wire you will need.
| Wire X-Sectional Area = |
| 1.7 * Current * Wire Length |
| Charging Voltage * Power Loss % |
|
So with the example
48V wind turbine generator which had a 65 Volt charging voltage and 30 amp maximum current, a 200 metre run of wire required, and no more than 10% line losses acceptable - wire with a cross sectional area of 15.7 square mm is required:
(1.7 * 30 * 200) / (65 * 10) = 15.7 sq.mm
Looking at the wires available on the market around this size there is 6 AWG (13.29 sq.mm) and 5 AWG (16.76 sq.mm). To keep line losses under 10% the 5 AWG would have to be selected giving 9.3% resistive line losses in this example.
Click here to visit our new automatic
Line Losses Calculator.
Converting and Understanding Wire Sizes
To
convert wire sizes from American Wire Gauge (AWG) to cross sectional area, mm diameter, or inches diamter click here to view our
Wire Size Conversion Table
Article Last Modified: 10:32, 8th Mar 2008Comment on this Article
If you have any comments on this article, please email them to
neil@reuk.co.uk.
Recommended Related Articles
People who read this article also enjoyed the following articles:
Line Losses CalculatorAn automatic calculator to work out line losses in DC powered systems
Article Last Modified: 10:31, 8th Mar 2008storage | generalAWG to Square mm Wire Size ConverterConvert between AWG, inches and mm diameter, and square mm area measures of wire size
Article Last Modified: 06:45, 19th Jul 2008storage | electric circuitSimple Solar Water Preheating SystemUse solar power to pre-heat water and reduce electricity/gas consumption
Article Last Modified: 14:47, 7th Oct 2009solar | heating | waterSwitch from Inverter to Mains AutomaticallyPower a circuit directly from a power inverter, but with automatic mains power back up.
Article Last Modified: 15:16, 19th Aug 2008electric circuit | storage | generalMake a Shunt ResistorMake your own rough and ready shunt resistor
Article Last Modified: 12:52, 28th Feb 2007electric circuit | educationSolar Battery Charger With LM317TFind out how to make a current controlled solar battery charger using an LM317T
Article Last Modified: 09:34, 30th Mar 2007solar | education | electric circuitBuild a Concentrated Solar Water HeaterPlans for building a cheap advanced solar water heating system
Article Last Modified: 10:14, 12th Apr 2007heating | solar | waterWhat Are UltracapacitorsFind out about ultracapacitors - how they work and what they are used for.
Article Last Modified: 16:38, 15th Dec 2008storage | electronicsStar Delta Wiring for AlternatorsLearn about Star and Delta wiring for wind turbine and other alternators
Article Last Modified: 13:39, 10th Mar 2008education | wind | hydroSolar Power for Europe from SaharaRead about plans to power EU entirely from solar electricity generated in Sahara Desert
Article Last Modified: 09:43, 23rd Jul 2008solar | news
|
|
|
